Stacks Image 36944
Appraising Papers
We could reinvent the wheel here or just be eternally grateful that there is a wealth of free on line material already available. Many thanks in particular to Simon Carley and the team at St.Emlyn's and BestBETs for producing some fantastic resources to help us all to critically appraise the literature. There are also some other superb resources which are linked below.

At TBL, we have adopted a PICO style for appraising our papers. The emphasis on our work is that we provide a summary, critique and end with the key point ('The Bottom Line'). We have included full papers (if available free on line) and/or abstracts. We have also linked any editorials or blog postings. As well as providing a summary and review of the landmark papers, we want to generate and host discussion on our website. Please contribute. We are already finding that this format is allowing us to readily discuss papers with key authors of papers and allowing the researcher and clinicians to be even more involved.
Stacks Image 16256
Stacks Image 16248
Downloadable checklists

Series of Podcasts from Simon Carley
  • Critical Appraisal for the FCEM exam
  • Statistics 1 & 2
  • Study Design: Diagnostic tests
  • Sample Size: The basics
An introduction to sample size calculations - St.Emlyn’s

And here are some more resources:
How to Read a Paper - series of BMJ articles

Centre for Evidence Based Medicine (CEBM) critical appraisal

Critical appraisal of a Journal article - University College London

Critical appraisal of the Medicine Literature - SIGN (includes feee online tutorials)
Dance of the p values
Geoff Cumming
School of Psychological Science, La Trobe University
Stacks Image 11969

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Disclaimer: The Bottom Line is intended for health care professionals. Wessex ICS (WICS), the authors or editorial board accept no responsibility for the accuracy or reliability of the papers that are presented or critiqued here. The presence of any linked articles, presentations, webpages and comments do not imply agreement with the information contained within, nor it is a measure of substantiation. Any comments made by health care professionals must be made responsibly and only reflect the opinion of that individual. Publication of these comments does not imply any form of agreement by WICS or Bottom Line. The webmaster reserves the right to remove any comments or membership. Use of this site is acceptance of this disclaimer